I have established that Face ID (at least for me) has problems with bright sunlight and strong shadows. We’ve got some great weather at the moment with days of cloudless skies and I’m outdoors a lot. Currently Face ID is failing 9 out of 10 times. If I move into a shaded area it then works.
This has been the case for me as well: If I am facing the sun then FaceID doesn’t work. My solution is to turn so that my head is between the phone and the sun, which seems to “fix” the issue reliably for me.
You said, that you “really hate” the FaceID, and under this circumstances, I would take the smaller one, so you do not need to “really hate” your iPhone!
In this thread others have hinted that Face ID is adaptive and learns over time. Maybe in the UK we just don’t get enough sunshine for it to have figured out what we look like in bright light
I can’t believe how much activity this post I made in 2019 is getting! One thing that has made Face ID a lot better is the addition of unlocking the phone from my Apple Watch, added during the pandemic because of mask wearing. But it also helps during the random times Face ID fails for all the reasons listed above. So now I don’t hate Face ID anymore.