Settling on Obsidian

I’m not a scholar in any of the PKM/PARA/etc approaches. I have some familiarity with Zettelkasten, enough to want to speculate about a novel set in a world where AI has become a settled part of the landscape. Diehard holdouts use simple tools to apply weaponized data against would-be tyrants, fighting enshittification from within. Unfortunately, like COVID, toxic data leaks out of their rag-tag fleet of aging RVs.

But, returning to topic, the idea that everything done in a PKM must adhere to ironclad methods is not attractive, particularly since alternative categorization can coexist in modern note-taking software.

I agree, do what you want. Bonus points for not orphaning ideas or facts.

That’s an important point. A lot of people seem to assume that if you use Obsidian, you have to adopt something like the zettelkasten method. The merits of zettelkastens have been oversold, IMO: « Luhmann used it and wrote a lot. So you should use it too. » You can easily find more important thinkers and scientists than Luhmann who used good old paper notebooks, people like Darwin and Newton for example.

3 Likes

Have you seen Colin Gorrie’s How far back in time can you understand English?

It’s a (fictitious) blog, written at the beginning in C20th English, but as the blog progresses, he moves the version of the English back another 1000 years – so the second section is as though it were written in 1900, the third in 1800, and so on back to 1000AD, by which time it’s almost completely unintelligible to non-experts.

It’s a lovely conceit, and I – emphatically a layperson in these matters – found it really interesting to watch the language change before your eyes.

4 Likes

I think too the note-taking needs and organizational requirements can change over time, and depend on purpose and project.

Pardon my obtuseness, but I don’t quite understand what you mean. When you opened an attachment (an image?) in Obsidian — how? What happened? Genuine question, as a newbie to Obsidian I’d be keen to understand this. Thanks.

I was referring to his question of why I dropped Notion and I was talking about Notion.

Oh I see. Sorry for misunderstanderising!

Well said. I don’t engage too much about the methods especially influencers suggest, and I create folders according to my needs. The reasons for using Obsidian is not that it’s powerful or variety of plug-ins. It’s the basic search workable, and it’s easier to turn drafts into documentation than Apple Notes. I still use it like what I do on Apple Notes.

How are you getting on with Obsidian. Every time I go back and try it I absolutely love the ability to have a calendar and quickly make a daily note for tracking work events, and the search works ok. I just have had a hard time with sync (used iCloud, remotely save, and self hosted live sync) and always end up with some syncing errors (I have MacBook Pro, iPhone, iPad mini and iPad Pro at home).

In general apple notes has been very solid, but I really do miss the ability to easily do a daily note with the calendar view. Still using obsidian? Any other changes to your apple notes workflow you noticed with the change good or bad?

I am still on Obsidian mainly, with a very few notes (e.g. security notes that can’t be done on Passwords) under a few circumstances (e.g. admin) on Apple Notes. Markdown notes are stored on iCloud with Keep Download on for my iPhone and iPad. They work well although Apple Notes works better. The only pain point is I have to download again most of the time after every OS update.

While I can get rid of every plug-in, if I need them, I find I usually get back to these plug-ins: Minimal Theme Settings, Style Settings, Notebook Navigator, Maps and Excalidraw. Up to these 5 plug-ins and no more. The only reason to use Obsidian and even Minimal Theme is that the title on note list and headers shown on outline won’t be trimmed. The other three plug-ins are just in case because I don’t need to be so minimal to strictly not allow them to exist, especially I don’t see them if I don’t need it.

That’s why it’s still okay on Apple Notes if I have to, but Obsidian has better interfaces with tabs. I also prefer the tree-view note lists. Files in Obsidian can also be used on other apps like iA Writer!

I tried Daily Notes but I don’t think I need to do it every day for the rest of my life. I just need some period of life when, say, I get lost in my life.

I find the daily notes the only thing I try to use. It is great to reference for work. The idea of linking does not work for me, it’s just a complicated Wikipedia that’s unnecessary. I’ve tried a shortcut for daily notes in apple notes but it gets messy quick.

I’m still working out how I’m going to use the 2 apps together (as apple notes is still the home for anything shared with my wife). I may ultimately give up on daily notes and maybe do a running “month note” on apple notes and call it a day, but we will see. I’m on my quarterly try the obsidian kick this week.

You can still use both apps dependent on different situations, unless there is an economic cost (e.g. subscriptions) involved.