4k or Ultrawide for MBP + HDMI

Work gave me Mac notebook. My own Windows desktop is for PC gaming. With this monitor, I could game and work.

1 Like

Windows for work, Mac for home. Sometimes I work at home.

1 Like


See the comments for the reported issues with Radeon Vega 20. Previously issues with Radeon 555x and 560x were also reported elsewhere. I haven’t seen anything about Nvidia.

1 Like

This is where I heard about it! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1xcjN-e-TUo

Good channel is that, been following him for a while! :slight_smile:

That LG 5K2K looks fab too, that’s another strong contender for when I get my office space built!

I have this same monitor (LG 38WK95C-W) along with my new Mac Mini (I finally retired my 2012 27” iMac along with a 2nd Dell 24” monitor next to it). So much cleaner on my desk now just having this 1 huge monitor - and I don’t miss having a 2nd monitor at all (I don’t need it). The monitor stand is perfect as well…does not take up much room at all and I can place all of my other things easily on my relatively small desk.

One thing that is bad though about this monitor - do not plug in any hard drives into the back of the monitor’s USB ports (I use the USB-C connection)! I had my Time Machine external drive plugged in and it would always disconnect itself every time I woke my Mac Mini from sleep (for whatever reason it would forcibly lose the connection to the drive and then re-connect, giving me that horrible disk ejected improperly message). I think this is why my Time Machine drive kept getting corrupted and I couldn’t figure out why - now I know. Took me weeks to figure out. So now all I keep plugged in is my Logitech unifying receiver for my mouse and keyboard, along with my Logitech Brio webcam (both work very well being plugged into the monitor itself, with full resolution to the webcam). I wish LG would fix the external hard drives issue with this monitor - it’s so weird that it forces a disconnection for a short period of time when waking from sleep.

I just bought the 29 inch gaming monitor, Did you managed to accomplish to display both Mac and Windows (Display Port and HDMI) at the same time. Any ideas or input on how to do it. I download the official control center from LG but can’t find where I can do this.

It’s doing the same for me too. I have my mechanical keyboard and mouse plugged into the back of the monitor, on both USB-A ports. When I wake up my (Windows) machine, I can hear sound that it made when one plugs in a new plug-and-play device. And I have to wait a second or two after the device is identified before I can use the keyboard. So, it is irritating and I’d imagine it to be worse on a Time Machine external drive.

I haven’t considered this yet - how about setting up the monitor to “Never” goes to sleep? There is a setting in the menu where it will auto sleep every 30 min, 1 hour or 4 hour. I remember seeing a “Never” option.

When I first have my monitor, I have done this before. You need to do it in the monitor settings (press the joystick and use the menu). There is an option to split screen and choose Display Port for the left screen and HDMI for the right screen.

My awesome reseller has a demo unit of the LG 5k2k, and I managed to test it with both my Vega 20 MBP and my windows notebook connected simultaneously. It’s easy to switch inputs with the little joystick hidden at the bottom of the display. The MBP worked fine using the native resolution. The windows notebook set the display to its maximum of 1920x1080, which results in 16:9 being stretched to 21:9. However, it suits me to have one display that’s as awesome as my MBP and works with the windows notebook as well.

2 Likes

I did try various options with them all leading to the same outcome (Auto Standby off, Smart Energy off). Nothing would change the outcome. I finally got frustrated and googled it and sure enough others have this same issue. I have since moved on and will never plug in hard drives to the back of the monitor! I’m afraid to even try my Drobo as I thought that was a recommended config with it going to monitor, then monitor to Mac. No way am I risking my Drobo data! LG needs to fix this or document it in the manual.

1 Like

Your Google-fu is good. I get frustrated googling for products such as these because all I see in the returned results are best prices from multiple websites… sigh!

I’m in the same boat… run Windows at work as an IT guy (and need Windows to do some tech-y things), but my MacBook Pro is my laptop of choice. Debating between the LG34WK95U-W, the LG 38WK95C-W, and potentially a Dell. So far the LG 34WK95U-W is highest on my list, but I’d love to get your thoughts after some time with it!

1 Like

I use this for 6 months already and love it very much. My primary machine for this monitor is a Windows machine and I also connect a MacBook daily to the monitor.

1 Like

I think my biggest question at this point is how the various LG monitors perform as far as switching between the systems in my use case. I’d have a MacBook Pro on the TB3 / USB-C input, and a Windows machine using the DP input. I understand it’s pretty straightforward on all the monitors to switch from the Mac to the Windows machine (and back again), or even split the monitors, but I’d really like to run these with a single keyboard and mouse – how do these systems do with KVM functionality? Thanks!

I’m wondering, worst case, if I went with the 5K2K LG monitor, perhaps I could move to the Logitech Craft / Flow Mouse system anyhow. Might be best of both worlds!

I think I can answer this question.
My mouse and keyboard is plugged into the two USB-A ports at back of the monitor. My Windows PC is connected from HDMI (in the PC side) into HDMI in the back of the monitor(*).

When I am using the MacBook, I plug the USB-C into the Mac and it detects the keyboard and mouse. This cable also display the Mac desktop into the monitor and charges the Mac.

When I am using the PC, I will unplug the USB-C cable from the Mac and plug it into a USB-C to A converter (included with the monitor). This converter is permanently plugged into USB-A port in the PC. In this case, the USB-C cable essentially acts as a mouse-keyboard cable for the PC. Yes, it sounds inconvenient to unplug and plug, but it’s no big deal in practice, as I am just unplugging it from the Mac and into the converter at the back of the PC.

The monitor can display both Windows and Mac side by side. In this case, the USB-C is plugged to the Mac. And you have to install a software KVM from LG (LG Dual Controller Driver) into both the Mac and the PC. So when you are trying to control the Windows desktop, the k+m is physically plugged to the Mac but the software KVM in the Mac talks to the software KVM in the PC to translate your k+m input.

The software KVM works ok if you absolutely must have two systems running side by side. In my environment, I use the PC for gaming and the Mac for productive work - so it’s better for me to have fullscreen (for one system) and physical k+m connected to get better response (in gaming) and as mentioned above, it’s just a matter of unplug and plug one small cable.

Hope this helps.

(*) I didn’t use the DisplayPort cable because the USB-C at the Mac is driven by Thunderbolt and the TB and DP share the same bus, so if you want to use DP, then you cannot have both PC and Mac showing side by side in the monitor.

Great info, thank you!

How do you switch inputs between displays?

I have a similar need (windows PC for work and MacBook for personal). In my home office i am connecting both to a 4K HP 27” monitor. It doesn’t work great. There are some issue with my PC video card driving this monitor, and switching between inputs requires a number of clicks on the buttons behind the monitor (menu, scroll down to input, menu, select USB C or DP). I wish there was an easier way, which it sounds like its one click on these LGs?

For keyboard mouse, i got the Logitech craft keyboard and a mouse. They have 3 BT connections that are super easy to switch between and the keyboard is pretty well laid out for going between Win/Mac. Much easier to click one of the dedicated connection buttons than mess with switches or cables. I didn’t install any of the Logitech software as my PC is pretty locked down. This all works out of the box.

The Craft keyboard is expensive, but it feels really good. I first bought one of the cheaper Logitech keyboards that switched between 3 devices (it had a built in stand for phones). I hated it. It didn’t feel right, the number keys too small, and was missing key keys i use frequently (pg up/dn home/end).

Thanks Jalm! Just ordered a Logitech Craft keyboard and a MX Master 2S mouse. Am guessing the 5K2K monitor will be a follow-up item early this week.

I have been using my LG 5k2k for a few months now, and short version - it’s great if you have the space and especially if you need to connect more than 1 computer to your display.
As reported above it’s easy to switch between MBP and PC using the input joystick. I also found a setting that lets the PC use the full screen without looking stretched. For those that need it, there’s a split screen function to show both machines at the same time.
To answer the KVM questions above:

  • I use a Logitech K811 which can switch between 3 inputs; I like that it’s small but some won’t like the absence of Home / End / Page Up / Page down.
  • I use a Mac mouse for the MBP and a Logitech Master MX 2S for the PC. I could of course switch the Logitech mouse between the two machines, but it stays in my work backpack, so I prefer to keep a dedicated mouse for the Mac.

I once or twice have had issues with the display not waking from sleep properly or the MBP going back and forwards on whether it has an external display when waking from sleep. This was resolved by rebooting the MBP and I think recent software upgrades helped too as I haven’t seen it happen recently.
I was also worried that the MBP was charging constantly (reported in another thread) but I think it’s really just driving the display or Safari that’s keeping it warm (54 C). Unzipping the Xcode beta drove it up to 100 C. When I wake it from sleep, it’s cold.

1 Like