I think one of the biggest things here is that comparing Notion to other notes apps isnāt quite right ā itās more akin to something like AirTable if you really push it.
I love the database capabilities of AirTable, however most people who need the information stored within AirTable are confounded by the shared views, etc. The report blocks of AirTable are limited to one page, making it useless when I have thousands of entries. Am I hearing right? Notion can output all this to an easy to use wiki like page (perhaps organized as an outline or something else people can understand)? Iāll be digging deeper into these YouTube videos. Thanks for this show.
This was really helpful in a way I wasnāt expecting. I fully expected to be going all in on Notion after this. But, now that I have a full picture of the benefits and downsides of Notion from a pro, I feel great knowing that what itās providing is not what I need and the tools Iām currently using are working out.
Exactly this.
I feel like I ought to love Notion and have come back to it two or three times, but I feel like I still havenāt quite nailed what has got everyone else so excited.
I think part of the issue is that while I understand that Notion potentially takes the place of two or three other tools (so that you have everything in one place), Iām not actually convinced it does thing as well as any of the tools itās trying to replace.
- Data can be inserted into a table, but it then canāt be mathmatically manipulated or outputted into a chart/graph. So why not just put the data into Excel in the first place?
- I can build a To-Do list, but itās not as easy as to just get tasks into an inbox as it is with something like ToDoist or Things (where I can use voice commands when needed suddenly or integrations with email platforms etc). Repetitive tasks are also an issue
- The big one for me is databases. I was so excited at the idea of relational databases interacting. And, while thatās the case of being able to pull static data from multiple places into new fields, I canāt actually mathematically manipulate values pulled from different tables into a new field.
I feel like I want to be much more of a dynamic tool, that I can login to and rely on what Iām seeing in some kind of central dashboard. Whereas instead, it seems to be much more static - and, as such, I need to update everything myself across a number of different tables, before I can rely on any kind of summary data.
As I say, though, it may well just be that Iām expecting the tool to be something that it obviously isnāt!
I tried to use notion for several times but i always come back to Evernote. I structure my note according to the P.A.R.A method. In notion i build a database Called Para and created different views for Project, Areas, Resources and Archive. My main issue was how slow the app was. It took seconds to scroll thru notes andā¦ it felt like it wasnāt a enough to ājust be a note takingā-app . It have all the bells and visible but i just need it for note taking.
Like having a truck instead of a sports car. You get what i mean.
I bounced off of Notion a couple of months ago, so I was excited to hear this one. Sorry to say I donāt think this episode is going to motivate me to give it another chance. It seemed like we spent a lot more time on how often the service is down than we did on what it actually does. I really didnāt get a sense of why Notion is worth checking out, let alone any cool MPU-like āI gotta try that for myselfā tricks or applications. I appreciated both hosts taking an extra shot at asking for a specific use for Notion in the second hour.
I have to be honest here. I appreciate the depth of knowledge and passion that Austin brought to the topic, but he seemed more like a fan seeking to defend what he loves than someone willing to look at the strengths and weaknesses objectively. Every time some sort of fault was raised, he responded with a dismissal. For example, promises of future features do not constitute an advantage over other products. Iāve seen way too many popular and fully funded software projects promise features for years and never follow through or result in half-baked results.
Two things hold me back from Notion and this whole category of open-ended life/work management systems: First, that I canāt afford to start from a blank slate. I donāt have time to build up templates and structures and all the rest. I need to do my work now. Thatās why off-the-shelf products are so popular (and partly why OpenDoc failed).
Second and related: The systems I have now work well enough. Sure AirTable has its flaws, but it works with Zapier today and looks like a database that I can use today. Sure, Google Sheets and Docs arenāt perfect collaboration tools, but they work well enough. The opportunity cost of starting with a new tool and getting buy in from everyone and getting it set up and working at least as good as what I have today, never mind better is just too high.
By the end of this episode, I didnāt have a better sense of why I should switch to Notion other than that it has a whole lot of capabilities that get some people very excited.
Again, I appreciate hearing about new tools and Austin obviously has a lot of knowledge that his clients benefit from, but I came away saying this isnāt for me.
Iām looking to replace Evernote with Notion when I can upload documents via an API. Bring on the API. Maybe then Iāll dabble further.
Interesting guestāI also wish heād let his guard down a bit more. His videos have a lot of specific steps to take to set up a ālife operating systemā in Notion and he seems to do better explaining the power of notion through that lens than advocating for it as a general organization tool or as a database.
Liked his story early on about organizing foundersā lives in order to be able to organize the startups they run, and it ties directly into that LOS work in Notion.
The Fifth Discipline is my favorite book about systems thinkingāif was mentioned, I overlooked it.
I went all in on the LOS a while back. Ultimately it was too much work for my needs.
Iām starting to do some lightweight task management in Obsidian now. Mostly marking notes that I need to work on #next or soon-ish #todo. I then have a template for my Daily Notes that has queries to collect and show me all the #next items. Itās kind of like the Agenda in org mode, but simpler.
I realize Iām probably atypical (Iām used to it )
I really enjoyed the episode and learned a lot even though I have no intention of using notion (I once went deep enough to realize it wasnāt for me). But I do intend to use some of the big picture ideas in rethinking some of my own processes.
Also, Iāve recently discovered Coda.io and absolutely love it. For some reason it works way more for what I want/need than Notion and I find a kind of simple joy in using it. At the very least, itās a great replacement for Google docs (but is so much more than that as well).
Iāve been using Notion for the last two months because I was invited to collaborate with someone who has been using it for some time (there are three of us on the project in total ā two newcomers to Notion). The project is complex, but mostly text driven. Iāve really enjoyed getting a feel for the software, and the collaborative aspect has mostly felt powerful (and, well, fun). Two things though that have been incredibly frustrating:
-
Itās slooowwww. There have been so many times waiting for it to load, waiting for it to sync. This has driven me bananas.
-
The commenting and @ system is really difficult to make sense of. Comments get lost easily and notifications seem to work better on iOS compared with MacOS. My other ānewcomerā colleague keeps missing @ mentions and I think this is a UI thing (sheās not particularly tech nerdy, but is also no slouch).
Iām pretty agnostic when it comes to various systems for PKM, notetaking etc. Still finding it hard to get past the DevonThink/Obsidian combo Iāve been using for some time (including collaborating on an Obsidian vault through a shared dropbox folder).
Cheers all, Simon.
Thanks for this. Iād made a notion account at the start of the year, attempted to replicate what I had in Airtable but couldnāt find a feature I wanted (it may have been there and I didnāt know what it was called in notion).
After this episode I thought Iād try it againā¦and I think itās going to stick. Iāve rebuilt my Airtable system (found the function I was looking for) and Iām loving having the database linked to my writing, rather than a number of different apps. Iām also finding it helpful to have all my information in one place. I often found that some things Iād not notice things which Iād stored in Airtable, since I was only looking at the columns that were most relevant.
Only downside - itās slowā¦in lots of ways! Like click the disclosure triangles in toggles takes a long time because the information is being fetched from the cloud. Bring on offline mode!
Great episode. I went into it hoping Iād be convinced to give Notion a try. However, it convinced me that Notion is definitely not for me. An interesting application but not one Iāll ever experiment with as I donāt have the time, and I have a system that Iām happy with (and which I think is better than what Notion offers), that covers all the functionality that Iād need.
Worth noting that Notion have acknowledged their slowness, and have publicly put a plan out there to solve it:
I agree with what others have said, this podcast reaffirmed my assessment that Notion is not for me.
Wow, just wow! Itās not often Iām blown away by a service or app, but Notion has blown my mind.
I am just starting to use Notion, but I already decided to replace Instapaper with Notion (using the web clipper) - just for that one part of capturing blog articles on the web. It occurs to me that I might be able to replace several apps/services I use with Notion.
It is so easy to use it is a little unbelievable to me.
Anyway, excellent podcast and topic and guest, as āusualā. Actually itās not usual for many other podcasts, but it is often usual for MPU I really enjoyed the episode!
Funnily enough, this episode finally made Notion āclickā for me. I know, right? Iām not sure Iāll get much use out of it, but I never fully understood the database mindset previously. I always just thought of it as a pretty free-form text editor. Digging into the database side of Notion really helps to see why so many people love it.
I donāt think itās helpful to use it for every area of your life, but I can see why people flock to it to manage sets of data that need to be displayed in different ways.
In June 2020 I sent @MacSparky a message suggesting August Bradley as a guest. I did not receive any response but glad to see that August was finally on the MPU show.
Blockquote
Hello David,
I heard that you mention that you will be getting into Notion and I would like to suggest that you contact August Bradley for a guest on MPU. August has skyrocketed off the charts in a short 3 month period on YouTube and has been made a Notion Pro status by Notion. His offering of templates and training of using Notion for a productivity system are exceptional.
Take a look at some of his videos.
With Kind Regards,
Dave
Blockquote
With so many good note applications available, I would not even think of using it for a note taking app in any form.
Same said for a task manager
I like the combination database/spreadsheet functionality so use it for:
Book Tracking
Movie Tracking
Subscription Tracking
Content Calendar
Inventory Tracker
As others have said it mainly compares to Airtable and one has to look at which application best gels with their mindset.
I thought it was a great show and glad August finally made it to MPU. August has put a wealth of content on YouTube.
Many people are far down the line with specific applications and to change horses mid-race is a time-consuming task so one has to look at the cost/benefit ratio and make the decision on apps that best suit their mindsets.
For me I am in the process of weaning myself off of Evernote onwards to Nimbus. I find Evernotes engagement with their users not to my liking and Nimbus has many of the features that I had wish Evernote would have such as getting stuff out of Evernote say in PDF format.
Right now I am enjoying MyMind and use it daily. It is by far the easiest way to get content from phone to Mac and PC of which I have to do many times a day