Take this post, for example.
The person behind it signs up, and the very first thing they do is create a post promoting their obviously AI-generated software on an equally AI generated website.
So far, they haven’t contributed anything else to the community. They haven’t participated in discussions, they haven’t helped anyone, and they haven’t shown any interest in being part of the community. They’re here for one reason only: to sell their software.
Then there’s the security aspect.
The software isn’t open source, so we have no way of examining what it actually does. The only contact information provided on the website is an email address. No phone number, no real business address, nothing.
They’re selling their app with a “lifetime license,” but what does “lifetime” even mean in this context? If the developer simply disappears tomorrow and stops responding to emails, customers are left high and dry.
I have quite a bit of firsthand experience with this issue, as I’m a moderator of r/macapps on Reddit.
We remove hundreds, sometimes thousands, of these posts every month, and we’ve established clear rules to protect our community. Even so, it often feels like we’re Don Quixote fighting windmills.
The only reason this forum hasn’t been flooded with these kinds of posts yet is that it’s still relatively unknown.
And no, I don’t believe the software section of this forum should primarily serve as a platform for self-promotion.
From what I’ve seen, people come here to discuss established software, exchange experiences, ask for advice, recommend applications, and help each other out. That’s what makes a community valuable.
All of that gets drowned out when, every two minutes, someone shows up with yet another post saying, “Hey, check out my app!”
There’s a fundamental difference between contributing to a community and treating it as a free advertising platform.