Advertising software in the MPU forum

I don’t think that it’s any different to how it was in the 80s in lots of ways, the main difference is that (pretty much) everyone has a computer in their pockets now.

In the 80s, many (not all) kids in school had a computer at home, just that the majority used them for playing games, when Game Consoles went mainstream (NES, Sega Master System, Sega Mega Drive, Atari consoles) the number of kids who had computers started to drift. The Atari ST and Amiga computers were good, but lots of the kids I knew effectively used them as game consoles despite having Graphical interfaces and being easier to use.

A subset (and a small subset at that) learned to program computers, made our own programs and games, pushed the boundaries, bought add on functionality like extra memory packs (ZX81 16k) and Electronic Drum Kits (ZX Spectrum 32k with the rubber keyboard). The Acorn Electron was the home version of the School BBC computer, but many kids in my Computing class at high school has very little interest in making the computers do things other than load games.

Wind forward to today and most people have a smartphone, but it’s still a subset who tinker under the hood, and due to the closed system nature of iPhones, it tends to be on Android. Those who are interested play with things like Arduino’s, Home Assistant, and Linux. It’s these kinds of people who download Apple X Code to build apps and setup AWS environments.

I don’t think that the ratio of people who are interested in getting under the hood is different at all to the 80s, I simply think that there are far more solved problems and the internet giving people the ability to do more with computers than needing to create your own. Of course those that still want to can and do delve deeper.

1 Like

I was actually thinking of Minecraft when I wrote that post, what with all the people who I’ve seen creating these huge 3D worlds. I’m just not sure if that’s what “the kids these days” get into. :smiley:

1 Like

My quick vote - for multiple reasons, the rise of drive-by automated or manual promotional posts has gotten bad and will get worse as tools make it easier.

I support a very restrictive policy as a baseline, with careful, thoughtful, decisions about opening it up, perhaps, over time.

A too restrictive policy only limits the ability for small devs to do free PR, versus a loose policy allowing a deluge of slop destroying the value of community strong forums like this. Better to be too restrictive, than too loose, IMHO.

As the mods have said, honest, thoughtful devs have the option to invest the time and energy to participate and become known for their contribution and app/apps.

A category for apps doesn’t just isolate the slop to one place; it still increases costs to operate this forum on multiple levels (time, hosting fees, moderators, etc.) and we all need to remember this isn’t a for-profit or even non-profit forum, it is primarily a gift from the podcast hosts to stimulate further discussion amongst the audience.

5 Likes

I don’t think “slop” is defined solely by whether it is the author’s first post. There have been numerous objections raised here in response to very appropriate first posts. Even worse - there have been objections after a software author engaged appropriately with a user.

The risk is not “only” that small devs will be unable to do PR. The bigger risk is that valuable long-term contributing members of the forum might move elsewhere.

Yes MPU is a “gift” from the podcast hosts. But it also relies upon a vibrant community of members interested in and willilng to engage on a wide variety of Mac-related topics. Censoring posts is not effective toward that end.

Bottom line - if you believe announcements of new software are “slop” then don’t read the Software section which was specifically set up for this purpose. That is so simple - problem solved.

1 Like

The software section is one of the main parts of the forum and for general discussion, to clarify. We wouldn’t introduce anything that would cause members to want to ignore that section.

4 Likes

Great- then perhaps divide it into “Software” vs “Software Announcements.”

Or whatever else you want to call it.

Just don’t censor posts about new software.

2 Likes

I think there should be some enforcement such as not allowing new members to post links in their first 2-3 posts

2 Likes

Good luck with that. It’s not going to change.

Take this post, for example.

The person behind it signs up, and the very first thing they do is create a post promoting their obviously AI-generated software on an equally AI generated website.

So far, they haven’t contributed anything else to the community. They haven’t participated in discussions, they haven’t helped anyone, and they haven’t shown any interest in being part of the community. They’re here for one reason only: to sell their software.

Then there’s the security aspect.

The software isn’t open source, so we have no way of examining what it actually does. The only contact information provided on the website is an email address. No phone number, no real business address, nothing.

They’re selling their app with a “lifetime license,” but what does “lifetime” even mean in this context? If the developer simply disappears tomorrow and stops responding to emails, customers are left high and dry.

I have quite a bit of firsthand experience with this issue, as I’m a moderator of r/macapps on Reddit.

We remove hundreds, sometimes thousands, of these posts every month, and we’ve established clear rules to protect our community. Even so, it often feels like we’re Don Quixote fighting windmills.

The only reason this forum hasn’t been flooded with these kinds of posts yet is that it’s still relatively unknown.

And no, I don’t believe the software section of this forum should primarily serve as a platform for self-promotion.

From what I’ve seen, people come here to discuss established software, exchange experiences, ask for advice, recommend applications, and help each other out. That’s what makes a community valuable.

All of that gets drowned out when, every two minutes, someone shows up with yet another post saying, “Hey, check out my app!”

There’s a fundamental difference between contributing to a community and treating it as a free advertising platform.

8 Likes

Obvously caveat emptor applies.

That said - I have found some gems in this sort of post.

We now have a dedicated software section. If you enjoy reading it (as I do) - great. If you do not trust it - then there are lots of other areas of MPU to enjoy.

1 Like

I think you’re missing several of the points I’m trying to make.

First, caveat emptor assumes that buyers have a reasonable opportunity to evaluate what they’re purchasing. But how exactly is an average user supposed to do that with software?

We’re not talking about buying a physical product where you can examine the materials, check the build quality, or easily determine whether something is defective. We’re talking about software that can potentially access personal files, credentials, and sensitive information.

Most users cannot inspect source code, even when it’s available. And when the software is closed-source, they have virtually no way of independently verifying what it actually does behind the scenes. They have to rely on trust, reputation, independent reviews, and the information provided by the developer.

Now consider a developer with no established reputation, no meaningful participation in the community, no verifiable business identity, and a website that provides little more than an email address. They’re selling lifetime licenses, but what does “lifetime” actually mean? What happens if they disappear tomorrow? Who is accountable if something goes wrong?

None of these concerns are addressed by simply saying caveat emptor .

Second, I don’t dispute that some genuinely excellent applications can be discovered through these posts. I’ve discovered some myself. But that doesn’t mean every developer should automatically be entitled to use an established community as a free advertising platform.

There’s a fundamental difference between a developer who participates in discussions, helps other users, contributes something meaningful, and occasionally promotes their work, and someone who creates an account for the sole purpose of selling their software.

Third, the argument that people can simply ignore these posts only works as long as they remain a small minority. If one out of ten posts is promotional, that’s manageable. But what happens when it’s ten out of ten? Or when hundreds of promotional posts bury the genuine questions, discussions, recommendations, and contributions that originally made the community valuable?

At that point, telling people to simply ignore those posts is no longer a solution. The promotional content is actively changing the nature of the community.

And that’s precisely the problem. Without reasonable standards, a community built around people sharing knowledge and helping each other risks becoming little more than a marketplace where developers compete for attention.

I’m not arguing that developers shouldn’t be allowed to promote their applications. I’m arguing that promotion should come with some basic expectations of transparency, accountability, and respect for the community.

Otherwise, we’re effectively telling developers that they can take advantage of an established audience without ever contributing anything to the community that built it.

And I don’t think that’s a particularly healthy direction for a forum like MPU.

9 Likes

But how exactly is an average user supposed to do that with software?

That’s up to each user to decide. I don’t believe MPU moderators can (nor want to) do that either. And the fact that a dev makes some posts doesn’t assure the quality of his software either. It’s all up to each user to decide for himself.

Indeed - that’s what MPU Forum is for! Let other users give their input.

Even better - what better way to judge softwware than to engage with the developer?? !!! That’s a stunning opportunity - why chase it away?

As for what if it gets to be a huge % of the forum? I don’t think we are anywhere close to that. The moderators can and should remove obvious spam. Beyond that - censorship rarely ends well.

2 Likes

So users are supposed to evaluate software themselves, yet you acknowledge that even moderators aren’t equipped to do that? That’s precisely the problem. How is an average user supposed to make an informed decision without the necessary information?

And calling reasonable moderation “censorship” is quite a stretch. MPU already has rules against spam and selling items, and moderators remove posts. Where exactly does moderation end and censorship begin?

Nobody is asking moderators to audit software. We’re talking about basic transparency and preventing a community from becoming a free advertising platform for people who have no interest in contributing to it.

1 Like

By engaging with the developer - and observing other users’ interactions with the developer also.

What an amazing opportunity.

We’re talking about basic transparency and preventing a community from becoming a free advertising platform for people who have no interest in contributing to it.

I agree! If we ask questions and they do not respond then that will speak for itself - quite loudly.

But the fact that it is a first post does not mean someone has no interest in contributing further.

I can remember myself at age 14 when I got my first job doing programming. I can imagine similar young developers now - and I think it woud be mutually beneficial for us to encourage new developers to share their softwware and make a few dollars.

If we find 1 star among 10 grifters so be it - that’s mutually worth the effort for both the new dev and his users.

So you’re essentially saying that having nine potential grifters in a community is an acceptable price to pay for discovering one good developer?

That’s quite a remarkable position.

And chatting with a developer doesn’t tell you what their closed-source software actually does. A friendly conversation is not a security assessment.

I agree that a first post doesn’t automatically make someone a bad actor. But why should commercial self-promotion come without even basic expectations of transparency or community participation?

Encouraging new developers and protecting a community aren’t mutually exclusive. I’m not sure why you keep presenting them as if they were.

1 Like

Of course we should expect community participation.

But it’s a circular argument - if they are defined as a “grifter” on their first post then how do they prove themselves?

I totally agree that if someone posts and then declines to respond to further follow-up then it makes sense to either ban future posts or retract their prior posts. That makes immense sense.

Encouraging new developers and protecting a community aren’t mutually exclusive. I’m not sure why you keep presenting them as if they were.

I don’t know of any better way to protect the community than to encourage their participation and let the community judge their responses.

By doing what everyone else does when joining a community: participating in discussions, helping others, sharing knowledge, and getting to know the people here. Why does their very first contribution have to be a sales pitch?

Nobody is automatically labeling first-time posters as grifters. You’re arguing against something I never said.

And once again, you’re ignoring my actual concerns about transparency, security, and accountability.

Community participation is not something that should only begin after someone has been given the opportunity to advertise their product. It’s supposed to be the reason they’re here in the first place.

2 Likes

The forum rules prohibit selling, so devs should not be posting anything which directly offers their software for sale.

TBH @johnkree i’m with you, but some people want to allow developers to use the forum as their research panel. :man_shrugging: Each to their own.

1 Like

AI is taking all kinds of issues, including this one, from a scale of one or two every now and scaling them, sometimes literally by orders of magnitude. Arguments for and against should take scale into account: something that’s not a problem when one person does it once in a while can quickly become problematic when it’s ten or twenty every day. I’m not saying that’s where we are here yet, but it’s certainly been the case in other venues.

3 Likes

Since joining the forum, I’ve never used mute until now and I’ve also now turned off notifications. I’ve also stopped having an mpu browser tab permanently connected. I’m really not interested in posts that want be to given feedback on their new product, especially new posters.

4 Likes