I would describe it as yet another example of the continuous improvement in hardware, software, and algorithms that we have benefited from for the last 75 years. Certainly not intelligence.
I don’t mind “AI leveraged”. But by “AI leveraged” I mean “somebody who otherwise has a clue what they’re doing using AI to assist them,” not “somebody who has never written a program more than a few hundred lines long typing a couple of prompts into Claude and releasing the result.”
Even in the age of AI, I still see it being about trusting the humans behind the AI. I don’t stress about Marco using AI to run down bugs in Overcast. But a random unknown dev doing a drive-by post about an app they just created needs more info for me to trust them - especially in the current security environment.
Agree 100% on this.
I do miss this. I know there are a lot of things that are “solved problems,” but I definitely appreciated the discussion David & Katie had back in the day about all sorts of new (to me, anyway). I’m wondering how much of this though is the fact that I’ve come along quite a bit as a Mac user, and how much is the fact that the vector of the show/forums/etc. has shifted.
I think you you are trying to get away with calling me a fool. Often fools will shake their fists at clouds. After 40 years in the business, I think I know something of how computers work and their history. I have always thought computers were amazing and capable of mimicking some of the things a human can do. But they are all still advanced machinery lacking intelligence, emotion, or agency (unless you’ve given them your password or they have managed to steal your credentials). ![]()
lol of course not. It’s an “old man” meme.

“Whippersnapper!”
…
I have tried to start “new app”-centric threads but they usually die off fast. There aren’t many explorers left.
There was a rant on (I believe) ATP once where Siracusa ended with,
“So in conclusion…‘whippersnappers!’” ![]()
Another favorite of mine is, “Get off my lawn!”
I thought this was resolved when the Software category was created.
It seems pretty simple to me - if you do not like reading posts about software, then do not read that section of MPU. Solved.
I particulary enjoy reading posts abot new software. One such post lead to an app I use reguarly now and that has been one of my best finds for the Mac in quite some time.
When I first started in computing (circa TRS-80 and Apple II) generally young people were the most knowledgable about its capabilities and the ones intersted in cutting edge software tools.
That remained true for quite a whie. But nowadays young pepole tend to view computers like they do cars- they use them as finished computer products but are nowhere near as likely to tinker under the hood as older generations.
I see this particuary when it comes to AI. I see people my kids’ age who either stick with standard AI chat engines or disavow AI entirely for perceived environmental reasons. At 60 I am way more knowledgabe about and interested in custom AI agents and MCP servers than those decades younger than me.
This is a total inversion of the way computing culture used to be.
Yeah, but, you know – whinging fuels forums. ![]()
Katie
…and this thread is no exception ![]()
I quite enjoy most of the discussions in the software category. Mostly it has been questions about various software programs, posed by people that use them for various things. I don’t want it to become a collection of “Please buy my software” posts.
I’m going to briefly lock this thread and move a digression on the definition of intelligence.https://talk.macpowerusers.com/t/defining-intelligence/47320
Just a quick note to say a huge thank you to @LisaSpangenberg and @cornchip for moderating. Many years ago I was a moderator on a politics forum, boy that was thankless and hard work. I really appreciate you doing this.
The early generations of computers could be taken apart, soldered, custom cards designed, etc. I mean, the Apple II shipped with a circuit schematic. So I think they appealed to younger people who found them new and novel and something to tinker with. Kind of like the younger people who enjoyed tinkering with muscle cars, only digital. And especially in the early days, tinkering with them was, frequently, the only way to actually get anything done with them. That and swapping disks at Ham Fest and such. ![]()
Now it’s all defined and productized. You can just buy what you want/need, and (frequently) it “just works”. For varying degrees of that phrase, of course.
And I agree on the inversion. I think a large part of it might be those people who had the original interest aging through the system. Although to be fair, I think modern younger people are more likely to be using the tech to tinker with other things rather than tinkering with the tech itself.
Maybe the tinkering impulse is manifested these days by 3d printing enthusiasts. Or even Minecraft.
Katie