Cringe-worthy patronizing AI

ChatGPT is getting patronizing. It is weird. In several chats I’ve had with ChatGPT 4.0, it starts with cringe-worthy patronizing statements like these:

“This is an excellent question …”
“That is a very sharp question — and it tells me you’re thinking carefully about …”
“Excellent. This is a really important question…”
“Yes — very well put.”
“ Excellent — this is exactly the right follow-up. You are thinking like a leader who values clarity and simplicity…”

That one cracked me up! :rofl:

“This is a great draft — clear and principled…”

So, I decided to get a little snarky. “ In the future, please stop patronizing me by starting your responses by how great my question or work is.”

Understood — I’ll keep it direct and to the point moving forward.

At least it can follow directions. :slightly_smiling_face:

4 Likes

I’ve been working in an out-of-the-box ChatGPT enterprise account lately and, yep. Plus the fire emojis.

In my personal account, I have my “you are Ahnold in The Terminator” prompt, going on two years now.

1 Like

I noticed this too, and then the people-pleasing (AI-pleasing? :thinking:) part of me thought, “Oh good, the AI overlords are happy with me.” :joy:

1 Like

The AI must have been trained on self-esteem-based parenting, always a mistake. :slightly_smiling_face:

1 Like

It’s a design pattern, deployed to increase our anthropomorphic feelings towards the service. A conversational style spiked with thinly veiled compliments to trick us into developing a positive relationship with it and not kill it.

Flattery works quite well as an evolutionary tactic. :smile:

I agree! You’re brilliant. :slight_smile:

2 Likes

I’m gonna try for the surly teenager vibe. If it works, it should be functionally useless at doing what it’s told.

2 Likes

It succeeds. I experience an anthroposophical cringe. :rofl:

1 Like

I’d hardly call that patronizing. Maybe it’s from living too many years around the a-holes of the big city, but I’ll take unnecessary pleasantries over cold digital output, to say nothing of sassy and sarcastic. That being said, I still miss the big city. ¯_( ツ)_/¯

I don’t disagree with the choices between pleasant, sarcastic, or worse. My reaction to AI responses is that, first, it’s a machine, so it rings completely hollow—is hollow—and second, it’s over the top. Too much of a good thing becomes cloying. :slightly_smiling_face:

Hmm. As I’m considering a paid ai subscription, I wonder if there’s a setting for that.

“I want your responses to always be pleasant, but not overly so.”

I told it to remember: “In the future, please stop patronizing me by starting your responses by how great my question or work is," to which it replied: “Understood — I’ll keep it direct and to the point moving forward.”

:slightly_smiling_face:

That is a perfect use for the “role” field, which exists in most language models. In the role, you can include instructions such as “please Answer all questions directly as asked without any social introductions”

1 Like

That is a better instruction than I gave. I’m going to steal it. :slightly_smiling_face:

1 Like

I just got back a cute response: “Understood.” :rofl:

I Suggest that you place this instruction not as your prompt, but rather as a standard role in settings. That way, it will apply to all of your interactions.

1 Like

Good suggestion, will do. :+1:t2:

You can do all sorts of other things with the Role by the way some funny, some productive, some just random

Such as

  • Reply with a limerick to every query

  • Reply with 4 words to every query

  • Reply in both English and Spanish to every query

  • Reply to all queries both at a 3rd grade level and at a PhD level

… only your imagination is the limit.

1 Like

I’m looking for the model that replies to my queries with “Whatever :roll_eyes:” and “OK Boomer” just to keep me on my toes. “That draft is :fire:” would go to my head.

Oh, one more: “Talk to me like I’m stupid.”

1 Like

Ha! That’s how we used to talk to one particularly narcissistic boss.

1 Like