I have a Magic Keyboard (current edition - the one that charges via Lightning) that’s dropping "i"s on the floor about 50% of the time. Basically, unless the key is actuated with the force dead-center, it doesn’t produce a letter.
This keyboard is less than three weeks old. At this point I can take it back to the store (Best Buy in this case) and get a replacement, or a refund.
I know the MacBook Pro keyboards have some issues, but I’m not aware of comparable issues with the Magic Keyboard.
If it were your keyboard, would you replace it with another Magic Keyboard? Or get something else? And if “something else”, any suggestions for a compact keyboard that works great with Mac?