My thinking was that maybe there’s a Lutron app that is somehow out of sync with Home. I don’t have anything Lutron, so don’t know how it works.
I’ve had this type issue with Hue, Wemo, and Koogeek at different times.
Testing it out currently. I did the config again on the Lutron app, the Home app auto-updated.
Will test and see how the other devices and my main device adjust.