My primary requirement for an iPhone 11 Pro case besides reasonable protection and grip is good button feel. I use the volume button(s) as a shutter release and the case I’m using now (top-rated at Wirecutter) has awful button feel—you just keep pushing with no tactile feedback that you’ve tripped the shutter.
I’m a photographer and with the capabilities of the XS and now the 11 Pro I find myself working on a project that relies heavily on the phone. Using the volume button for picture-making is critical to the work and good button response is critical to getting the picture without movement.
I have this case for my 11Pro. Button feel is subjective, and I’m not a photographer, but they work and I have no complaints. I like that the phone can be easily separated from the case for use as a gps, when taking pics, and other times you don’t want your credit cards and ids flopping around.
My last two Bookbooks fell apart within a year - really disappointing compared to previous ones. I’m back to a wallet, and an Otter Box case from the Apple Store. Feedback is great for the OP’s needs.
I have the rugged case from Nomad. The feel (and smell) of the leather is great and it is very protective. Buttons feel solid. They have a XS case for the Moment lense, so maybe one for 11 will come as well.
I recently purchased a Totallee Leather case for my iPhone 11(non-Pro). I’ve owned Apple Leather cases for my 4s & 6s and find this case to be superior to those.
It has “… metallic button covers that feel like just the iPhones actual buttons”. I would prefer to not use a case, but this is the next best thing. It has a good feel and enough of a lip to protect the screen and camera when you lay it down. $45.
I use the Apple Silicon case. I think the button feel is very nice in this one, and the silicon material ensures a good grip. I also like the low profile and minimal added bulk to the phone. Going on it’s second year now, it is beginning to come apart a little, but I will probably get the same type of case again when I update in January.