LLMs, Chatbots: Beware the Intention Economy from Harvard Data Science Review

This article is not surprising but is disturbing. I don’t see a way to avoid some of this unless one “goes off-grid,” an impossibility and undesirable for most.

This new dimension of automated persuasion draws on the unique capabilities of LLMs and generative AI more broadly, which intervene not only on what users want, but also, to cite Williams, “what they want to want” (Williams, 2018, p. 122). We demonstrate through a close reading of recent technical and critical literature (including unpublished papers from ArXiv) that such tools are already being explored to elicit, infer, collect, record, understand, forecast, and ultimately manipulate, modulate, and commodify human plans and purposes, both mundane (e.g., selecting a hotel) and profound (e.g., selecting a political candidate).

2 Likes

I did not read the full article, however I only use LLMs running locally on my machine, eliminating any data collection. There are a number of tools for this, the one I use is Ollama.

1 Like

This was a good read; thanks. Online markets can communicate with and sell to us to the extent we are continually immersed and completely expressive participants. I see the new capabilities as being additive rather than a new paradigm, e.g. if Facebook could mine 24 hours of conversation on Messenger rather than the few most friends can offer. Just one thought and not a reduction of the essay.