Macrumors Forums: Toxic`

Anybody else here a user of MacRumors Forums? That’s where I’ve migrated from. Despite being a really decent Apple news site, the forum aspect - despite being possibly the most active and alive Apple forum online - is toxic. The anti-Apple rhetoric, whilst of course, is a reality with differing opinions and perfectly fine, completely over-rules and drags down otherwise great discussion of all things Apple.

The reason I felt the need to post here is to see if any of you guys agree with what I’m saying and have had a similar experience. I’ve had a few bans from there now on multiple accounts, but I give up because no matter how reasonable you try to be you’ll be outnumbered by negative ‘anti-Apple bullies’, who themselves are backed up by some what I assume to be freelance moderators who also dislike Apple and will remove posts, paragraphs etc. on some of the hottest discussions without explaining themselves and leave a very one-sided discussion there. I post just as I do on here, and I’m sure you’ll agree that’s hardly obscene or insulting toward anyone.

It’s a real shame. I find the discussion here, whilst a smaller community, much higher quality - even when someone is against Apple in their views. There is less bias.

Share your experiences if you have any like this?

3 Likes

News site forums are the YouTube comment sections of text based media.

I wouldn’t even dream of clicking the link.

In fact I have 1Blocker remove the comment sections of almost all websites. Don’t even have to download the waste of bits.

6 Likes

MPU is the only forum I’ve ever stayed on for a decent amount of time. I can only think of a couple of conversations that got heated, which is pretty great going for a forum.

I always think about how big a community do I really need to be in? MPU may be relatively small, but still I don’t know all the people here and there’s more chatter than I can reasonably keep up with; and with how nice everyone is, why would I want to get bogged down in anything bigger when I could instead spend my time creating something?

Nice idea about 1Blocker, by the way.

4 Likes

I’ve been on MacRumors since 2007 and have posted 15 times in those 12 years. Mostly with questions about whether an app work with an OS update. I’ve never had a bad experience but I’ve seen lots of snark in the threads I’ve read.

1 Like

It baffles me that anti-Apple people would bother to go to the trouble of registering for an Apple news forum.

That said I don’t understand people commenting on any news or YouTube channel in the way they do.

Maybe I’m getting old.

1 Like

100% my experience. I looked up a couple of people who trolled me and this one guys posts three times a day on anti-apple rants and has for about two years. I’m thinking his ex-girlfriend (maybe pretend girlfriend) must have really like Apple. That site has become almost unusable. Thankful for this community for sure.

2 Likes

I mean, any experience of social media should have prepared you for this phenomenon. This is literally the basis on which Reddit exists :joy:

1 Like

I’ve posted there since October 2009, 4706 posts but only 7 this year. I don’t use that much new Apple gear nor the latest OSes, which is where most of the activity is on MacRumors. Never had any problems with trolls, but I rarely post or read the forums on the News. Since MPU forums came on line I spend far more time here.

2 Likes

Even Reddit has good discussions on specialized topics - although they’re not easy to find.

I was active on the MacRumors forums until a year or two ago. I only go there now if I’m doing a quick search for experiences related to weird hardware or software issues that I’m seeing. The MPU discourse forums are both a better community fit for me and have better navigation tools. And, yeah, there was something weirdly random and not particularly helpful about the behavior of the moderators on the MacRumors forums that I sometimes found irritating.

2 Likes

I think comment sections (and therefore forum comments) all over the web can be pretty rough. I see some pretty brutal treatment out there.

It makes me incredibly thankful for this discussion group. Every now and then a topic may get a little heated here, but it’s nothing like other parts of the web. People here treat people with respect and dignity — quite refreshing!

Thanks to the mods including @RosemaryOrchard for that!!!

5 Likes

Glad I’m not the only one! Yes, this forum is fantastic. I love the software that it’s based on, whatever it’s called. There are some pretty bad and clunky old ones out there, but this is the most modern and user pleasing interface I’ve seen yet - truly fit for an Apple fan community.

The software is Discourse, and it provides a really nice forum experience. A lot of software developers have been using Discourse in recent years for their forums.

Katie

I follow Macrumors to stay up on Apple news items, software updates, new third party products, etc. The Macrumors forums on Apple-related products and their use or troubleshooting can be helpful at times as well. With their large user base, those forums are also useful to spot early problems with Apple software updates. But the comments from some users there are sometimes snarky and not helpful, especially if you are trying to get help with a problem. Topics often veer off course, and it takes a lot of effort to go through some threads to glean any useful information.

Macrumors is a for-profit site as far as I know, so getting a large user base and having a lot of clicks makes sense for them financially. For the user, however, it can be an unpleasant experience. And their politics thread is a complete dumpster fire. There are about 10-15 regulars who post dozens of rude, intolerant and insulting messages at all hours of the day, every day, and the moderators tolerate it for financial reasons in my opinion. Personally, I think those folks have some kind of pathology about being online, similar to a social media addiction. I’d much rather spend my online time here with happy productive people.

2 Likes

Consulting the MacRumors buy/don’t buy advice is an essential step when planning any Apple upgrade. I don’t read their forums. I get Apple news through RSS and the MacRumors feed is one that I follow. The one I go to for in depth articles is Appleinsider and I also enjoy their podcast and the related Space Javelin podcast. I tried posting to Appleinsider forums about a specific issue I had but I didn’t find it a useful experience.

1 Like

As self selected and cloistered as this and really all online groups are, they are still part of this world and therefore reflective of the world. The ills anywhere are an expression of what is incomplete and unfulfilled within each of us. There’s really no escaping our connection with each other. The lovers rejoice in their experience of connection while those who connection is diminished seek that experience in any way they can.

I suggest seeing their struggle with compassion and take it as the highest expression of love they can currently muster. This compassionate embracing of our own and others incompleteness will melt whatever is there. Miracles will occur. The lotus takes the muck and sludge from the bottom of the lake and transforms it into something beautiful. Each of us can do the same.

It takes something to do this. Sometimes I find it helpful to remember this quote by Rilke~

"“Be patient toward all that is unsolved in your heart and try to love the questions themselves, like locked rooms and like books that are now written in a very foreign tongue. Do not now seek the answers, which cannot be given you because you would not be able to live them. And the point is, to live everything. Live the questions now. Perhaps you will then gradually, without noticing it, live along some distant day into the answer.”

2 Likes

They’ve got an ‘Alternatives to Mac’ section which is largely formed of people who have a sour taste in their mouth from past personal experiences with Apple. Mostly issues such as the butterfly keyboard.

They’re all self-acclaimed “Pros”, who ‘for their line of work, you wouldn’t understand’ - despite rarely disclosing what they do. And anyone who likes Apple is nothing but an Apple apologist and ridiculed and bullied out of threads. Whilst Apple apologists do certainly exist, it’s still not a crime to like / recommend the products.

I encourage any of you to take a look at it for yourself if you’ve got a bit of spare time. Sometimes they make valid points and the frustration is certainly worth venting, for example like some of the prices for repairs at the Genius Bar and the lack of genuine spares being available etc that I wholeheartedly agree with and see their point, but if you don’t think the Dell XPS 15 is superior or ThinkPads are superior to any Mac, ever, you’ll not fit in with the regulars.

Fun tip: They like to talk about how they’re Linux power users, but ask any of them for software recommendations or why they use Linux beyond the vague expression of ‘freedom’, and they’ll suddenly go quiet.

This is my genuine (albeit negative) experience. I haven’t found anyone overly irrational on here about being for or against Apple. But, as you’d expect, we’re mostly all here because we love our Apple devices. And that’s what makes it great to me!