What are your thoughts on iCloud Private Relay?

Hey guys, I just wondered when I first heard about the iCloud Private Relay and was amazed that it can mask our identity without using the VPN or Proxy. But I wanted to know if it is a replacement for VPN? And can we rely it on completely? Please let me know your thoughts on it.

I wouldn’t call it a VPN replacement, especially depending on what exactly you need from a VPN. While I have found it very useful, it’s also limited by the fact it’s only accessible through Safari. If that’s all you use and (unlike me) you don’t care about video streaming from other locations, it could be your silver bullet. It’s just hard to pin down when I don’t know your VPN use cases.

It is a very good and very cool technology. It works great at hiding your IP address from websites that you visit in Safari. Safari has better than decent fingerprint tracking protection too.

The main issue with Private Relay is that it only works in Apple services. So, your traffic through other browsers and apps is not relayed and your IP address is exposed.

A VPN on the other hand can mask your IP address in all apps.

There are other differences too like with VPN you can bypass geo-restrictions etc.

Specifically speaking about browsing with Safari, Private Relay will hide your IP from websites just as effectively as a good VPN while (generally) providing better performance and less captchas.

2 Likes

iCloud Private Relay is very different from a VPN.

IPR is (as the name suggests) a way to stop your location/IP Address being visible to either your destination or those who could intercept your traffic in between.

A VPN can serve a similar purpose, but also protects your data in transit by encrypting it between your computer and the VPN Endpoint.

There’s something to say in this day and age the majority of your traffic will likely be encrypted in transit due to the use of HTTPS as standard, but that assumes that all of your traffic is web traffic and not (for example) Email between servers (which can’t be guaranteed to be encrypted in transit).

As @MacinTosher also points out, IPR is only going to work for Apple Devices for Safari traffic.

I don’t agree with this though. VPN services can be variable and there’s no guarantee that IPR is faster than a VPN.

My stance is it helps and doesn’t get in my way. It’s included in my subscription for storage and I primarily use safari on my Apple products, so why not get a little extra privacy protection since I’m paying for it.
I do use a real VPN at airports and some sketchy coffee shops, which really isn’t that often.

1 Like

I generally leave it off because every so often when I turn it on, I will eventually wonder why ā€œthe internetā€ isn’t working. Fairly quickly these days, I go straight to IPR and turn it off and miraculously things start working again.

Now, it’s not really ā€œthe internetā€ that stops working, but specific sites. Not crazy sites, either. I couldn’t give an example, but I’m sure it’s just ā€˜ordinary’ sites I wouldn’t think are doing silly things under the hood.

1 Like

I think this has come up before in the forum, but I’m too lazy to look. First things first, there are MANY types of VPN and technically speaking iCloud Private Relay is one of them. It’s plenty fast because of the underlying CDN’s that support it and their breadth of coverage. I trust Private Relay much more than I do VPN services on the internet.

1 Like

I too have had inconsistencies with IPR on, before finding out that pi-hole my ad-blocker and internal DNS server does not support it. Switched pi-hole for Techtinium DNS and IPR is now working as advertised.

If you use similar products, I’d recommend checking for IPR support.

Thanks, but nope. It’s even happened when I’ve been trying to access something on the phone while on cellular.

I’m sorry, but simply by parsing the name VPN (Virtual Private Network) i.e. segregation of your traffic from that of others, IPR is not a VPN.

Good grief…. A GRE tunnel is a VPN, making a phone call on a POTS telephone line establishes a VPN. There are MANY types of VPN.

Do you even understand what happens when a VPN connection is established? You’re making the assumption that the tunneling and encryption are always the same thing; they’re not. Modern VPNs tend to combine the two but this isn’t always the case. VPN’s also have use cases beyond security.

Does iCloud Private relay tunnel encrypted traffic? Yes. Hide or translate IP’s? Yes. Encryption? Yes. DNS? Yes. VPN…

So disagree all you want; won’t make you less wrong….

A virtual private network (VPN ) is an overlay networkthat uses network virtualization to extend a private network across a public network, such as the Internet, via the use of encryption and tunneling protocols.[1] In a VPN, a tunneling protocol is used to transfer network messages from one network host to another

A VPN provides Tunnelling AND Encryption across a public network. (Although it doesn’t always have to be across a public network). You can Tunnel or encrypt, but a lack of either means it’s not a VPN.

Thanks for the copy and paste; but my understanding of the technology goes beyond that.

Do you even know what tunneling means? Do you know what happens when a packet moves between nodes on a network?

iCloud Private Relay takes your request and then encrypts them, and then wraps them in another data packet. Guess what an IPSEC VPN does? Wait for it…. Same thing. A VPN can include a set of functions and isn’t always deployed for security purposes. It’s also can include a set of technologies; not just one thing (See IPSEC over GRE).

You’re the same person that argued with me about software discounts only to see it published about six months later in the US that the government did exactly what I discussed. You don’t truly understand what you’re talking about. Just arguing for the sake of arguing…

No, I worked in IT and networking for 15 years, held a CCNA, and now work in Info Sec so I know nothing of what you’re speaking about. Sarcasm

iCloud Private Relay encrypts your DNS requests, not the information which is actually being relayed.

You can define a VPN however you wish, but the wider industry doesn’t define it as you do.

There are several academic papers on the internet which define the two technologies differently, some are sponsored by VPN providers so should be read with healthy scepticism. There are many pages with explanations of the differences between the two.

But there are no prominent claims (other than early reports from the release dates on IPR that it is a VPN, which were quickly challenged correctly) that IPR is. VPN

I like a healthy argument, but as someone who hates when people perpetuate ideas which are not true. I call them out. There’s a risk that people believe IPR is more than it is if it’s equated with a VPN.

Do I come across as argumentative? probably, it’s always a risk when there’s only text and no context. I hope I’m always respectful though and if we discussed this face to face, I hope you would see that I’m merely sharing my experience, not arguing just for the sake of it.

I’m done with this now though, so say what you will. Other participants can read our challenges to each other and go and research if they wish to make their own minds up.

4 Likes

The key benefit is that it is a flocking technology. So your browser is supposed to look like part of a mass of browsers and can’t be distinguished from others.

1 Like

Same here. I use NextDNS which works very well to prevent tracking and ads but when I turn on IPR, many ads are no longer removed. I assume that IPR still prevents tracking, but I just turned it off and never looked back.

In my mind IPR is not really a feature for power users who have other ways to prevent tracking. The reason why NextDNS and especially Pihole are not for everyone is because those services do occasionally render websites or apps dysfunctional due to the grey zone of dual use services like Piano, which tend to be classified as trackers but also do other things like handling logins (which arguably requires a form of tracking). Good website design will hide such essential services behind local urls, but not all websites are perfect so that you have to manually whitelist a domain or temporarily turn off NextDNS. So - again: in my mind - the service that Apple provided with IPR is to provide some privacy without burdening the user with any of that.

I’m just seeing this reply, and after reading it I just have to reply.

Not sure which part of this is sarcasm. I hope it all was…

:x: WRONG :x: - Like I said before, the traffic is encrypted. Uses HTTP/3 and QUIC because (wait for it) TLS 1.3 is built in. See the Private Relay Whitepaper - Read it when it came out, that’s why I knew this from memory.

:x: WRONG AGAIN :x: - Go re-read some of those Cisco press books from your ā€œCCNAā€. Here is is references since I’m just telling lies. This is from way back in 2006. I can go on…

ā€œIn its simplest form, a VPN is a set of nodes on a public network—such as the Internet—that communicate among themselves using a private network. In fact, a GRE tunnel by itself is a VPN. Although it does not provide any data-confidentiality or data-integrity services, it does provide a point-to-point private connection between two nodes.ā€

I’m not trying to be argumentative either, and I don’t have an axe to grind.

But I’m not going to sit back and let you say I’m making things up. I don’t say much, but if I do there’s usually a reason…

EDIT: Re-read the thread. I don’t even know why I responded. You clearly don’t get it. Just leaving this so everyone doesn’t think I’m ā€œperpetuating ideas that aren’t trueā€ā€¦

I am no expert on this field, but I love the friendly atmosphere in this community. And this does not feel friendly. :frowning:

From the white paper you linked to:

DNS name resolution

DNS is the system that translates server names into IP addresses when using
the internet. The ability to observe DNS lookups allows potential trackers to monitor user activity. To protect the privacy of DNS name resolution for all queries sent by the device and prevent such tracking, Private Relay uses Oblivious DNS over HTTPS (ODoH). ODoH sends DNS queries through the first internet relay, so the DNS server cannot identify the user issuing a query. Each query itself is padded and encrypted using Hybrid Public Key Encryption (HPKE) to help ensure that the first internet relay cannot tell the domain name a user is looking up. To ensure that DNS answers retrieved over ODoH are correct for the network that the device is on, the device is able to learn its public IP address subnet from the first internet relay and send that value in the encrypted query to the DNS server using the EDNS0 Client Subnet option.

Be it as it may…

Every morning, the sun will rise again and send some energy and happiness. This has happened quite some times during the last 3 months. Just let it go and make the world a happy place. :dove: There is enough nonsense going on already… :sun_with_face: :wink:

2 Likes

I am genuinely sorry if I offended anyone. I guess this is how I’ve had to operate in the circles I operate in. The red X’s may have been much, but this is the second time this has happened. First time it was implied I was a liar to have what I was saying later confirmed when it became public. This time I’m ā€œmaking stuff upā€.

Your quote would be fine if I ever said the DNS wasn’t encrypted; it is. Both things can be true. Which begs the question: why search for a snippet to prove me wrong (only showing yourself to be wrong) and then come back with the sun shining and spreading happiness? Was that genuine? If you truly wanted to do that you wouldn’t have come back with an incorrect retort.

The number one reason I don’t use Private Relay is it occasionally triggers a false security alert. Banks, etc. apparently suspect foul play when your location jumps from location to location, at faster than light speed. :grinning:

Everything about me has been sold, leaked, or downloaded from the US government. I’m tired of pretending anything is private.

1 Like