Why is Apple Notes search so slow and inaccurate on Mac?

Hi!

I’m having a really frustrating issue with Apple Notes search and I’m starting to lose my mind (on mac). This problem started after i updated to MacOS Tahoe

The search is slow, and it often doesn’t show what I’m looking for even when I type the exact title of the note. The note won’t appear under “Top Results”, but if I scroll further down the results list, I can eventually find it.

I’ve already tried the following, but nothing helped:

I signed out of iCloud on my Apples notes on Mac, restarted, and signed back in so all notes had to re-download.
I disabled Spotlight indexing and enabled it again to force a re-index.

But the problem is still there.

Has anyone experienced the same issue and found a fix? Is there anything else I can try to make Notes search work properly again?

It works great nn my iPhone and iPad

Thanks in advance!

1 Like

I wish I could help, but this is my experience on iPadOS as well. It’s why I can’t go all in on Apple Notes or trust it in a moment of need. Search is just too unreliable.

3 Likes

I’m sorry you are having that problem.

I have slightly over 1,100 notes in AN. Search on the Mac running Tahoe has been reliable for me. I’m able to find most anything I need. For example, I ran a search for “Southwest.” The search not only revealed notes with the word, but also included PDFs where the word was found. I ran several other searches before replying to your post to see if I had trouble finding what I was searching for. I did not. AN’s search is not nearly as powerful as something like DEVONthink, but I’ve had no problem finding what I’m looking for.

I hope you find a solution.

1 Like

Before the update, Apple Notes search worked perfectly like your example @Bmosbacker . Now it suddenly doesn’t.

I’m wondering if this could be an indexing issue.

Does anyone know the best way to completely reset things, for example:

  1. Remove everything locally on the Mac
  2. Clear / reset indexing
  3. Re-download all notes from iCloud
  4. Let Apple Notes rebuild the index from scratch
1 Like

Unless you’ve just posted on Reddit, under a different name, you’re not the only one having problems. Both these posts are by the same person. One is a year old, the other just 5 hours.

It appears large complex documents can also be a problem.

https://www.reddit.com/r/AppleNotesGang/comments/1q3tcwr/why_is_apple_notes_search_so_slow_and_inaccurate/

https://www.reddit.com/r/AppleNotesGang/comments/1iny9v0/new_apple_notes_are_really_lagging_but_only_when/

Good luck.

Thanks @WayneG WayneG. The first post is mine!

1 Like

And the other is someone else. I need to read more carefully, or have my eyes checked. :grinning:

1 Like

I’m not certain if this is your practice, and even if it is, it might not be relevant. However, I don’t store many large files in Apple Notes. I have some PDFs, but the notes are primarily text. I store all my research files in DEVONthink. I don’t believe Apple Notes is designed to serve as an archival system for numerous notes containing PDFs. It is primarily for taking notes; I’m not sure Apple envisions Apple Notes serving a “database” function. I may be entirely mistaken about this, but that’s my intuitive thinking.

Have you asked the all knowing A!? :wink: