I’d try them first. Do be aware though that foam tips are a consumable part - you’ll need to replace them every couple of months since the foam degrades.
On somebody’s recommendation I got the Comply foam tips and they have been great for me. They stay in better and are more comfortable for long periods. I bought the assortment first to find which fit me better then ordered a set of the correct size.
I’m the OP from that misshapen ears thread – I found that the “ear hooks” actually worked better for me than the foam tips did; I used them on my old 1st gen airpod pros primarily for running. I’d still have to adjust/re-seat my R one a few times during the run but only about 40% or so as often with the wings than without them. I stopped using foam tips after I found these; did not seem to make a difference for me with or without the wings. It is mildly annoying to have to remove/replace the wings every time you use them as the buds will not fit inside the charging case with them on, but this only takes about 5 seconds, and the ones I bought came with a handy silicone case that attaches to a keychain. I had to use a key fob to get in to my gym anyways, so these were always right at hand when I needed them.
They set of wings I bought don’t fit the 2nd gen AirPods pro but looks like they’ve released an updated version that does - here’s the Amazon link: https://a.co/d/buePJpW
I haven’t tried the new ones, I find the 2nd gen airpod pros fit slightly better for me than the old ones anyway. Hope this helps!
I too use the “ear hooks.” My AirPods Pro 2Gen will kind of stay in my ears, but not with a seal that passes Apple’s sound test. But if I’m exercising at all, they fall out. The hooks keep them in place, but again not with a seal that will pass the Apple test for sound cancelation etc. I tried foam tips, different size ear tips from Apple, just about everything else out there. The hooks aren’t a perfect solution, but they work well and are cheap as can be.
I had wondered about the ear hooks. The annoyance factor is what has kept me away so far.
This is what has made me hesitate. I purchased: Amazon.ca
In the ML size. These are a bit better than the stock ear seals. However in a sixty minute rowing session yesterday, I had to nudge them back in 5 or 6 times. (Which is way better than the official Apple ones).
Thanks for posting the product link. Those look quite interesting. I wonder how the sizing compares to Apple’s. I could see myself ordering the wrong size.