The Roam team have banned a bunch of users from their subreddit for negative posts. There’s a full explanation of reason, and the new rules in the subreddit here
I’m conflicted about this and interested in the views of others are. On the one hand, I get that the sub needs to be moderated to avoid it descending into the cesspit that’s been the fate of so many others. On the other hand, routine active moderation could address that risk: this seems a little extreme, if not overly defensive.
As a member of that sub since its inception, I haven’t seen a whole lot of the kind of thing the team are objecting to: plenty of criticism in the earlier (2019-20) days concerning support and reliability; plenty of robust debate on future direction and priorities; a little “you should use Product X 'cos it’s so much better”, but not that much. As a contrast, the Notion sub is often wash with complaints about its limitations and risks.
Among the more disturbing comments in the Roam guy’s post is this:
“If you would prefer not to use Roam, we prefer that you find another subreddit” - why wouldn’t a non-user want to use the sub to find out more. There are pellet of non-users who are curious - they’re not all sockpuppets for the competition
And this:
" In fact, despite this subreddit being substantially smaller than our number of paying users (smaller even than just the subset of users on free or highly discounted plans) – this subreddit seems filled with people who aren’t even using Roam!
The result has been, pretty much no one on our team enjoys spending any time on here
Since jumping into the community is generally more a recreational activity during phases where we’re focused on deeper work (like this past year) - the result is we basically never show up here
The team steering clear of the reddit means there is little incentive for the more knowledgable and creative members of community to wade in
The incentive is lowered even further when the posts that are most rewarded are ones that are most critical"
In summary: we only come here when we feel like it, and because people aren’t nice, we don’t feel like it
Maybe I’m being unfair (which is why I’m canvassing other opinions), but that all really sounds like the “cult” mentality that Roam’s been accused of. It comes across to me as a demand that you fall in line with the clique or get lost. Of course you want a supportive user base, support doesn’t mean nothing but pats on the back. And there’s an obligation for Roam to support its users - which it still struggles to deliver.
Thoughts?